I'd like to know. Because I'm a curious guy.
I can tell you why I am an Episcopalian. I like the whole theological style of this outfit. The Via Media. Balancing Scripture, reason and tradition. Maybe add to that common sense (though perhaps that falls under the "reason" category).
As to Scripture, it can be argued that we Episcopalians do not emphasize this sufficiently. We hear it read to us in the liturgy, which causes a somewhat choppy treatment of the text. And then the sermon explicates it to some limited extent. Frankly, that's enough for me. Weekly (and sometimes more often) bite-sized chunks. I grew up in a "fundie" church, where Bible texts are used to prove the most outlandish things without any tether to human reason. I don't want a church where I have to park my brain at the door and become a glazed-over yes man within. Don't beat me over the head with the Bible. I've had enough of that.
As for reason, I think any reasonable person can perceive that the path of the ethical and spiritual development of humankind is towards inclusiveness. Jesus constantly broke down the social codes of propriety and shame. He consorted with sinners and outcasts, and blew off the priestly caste. Jesus's approach foreshadowed the words Edwin Markham:
They drew a circle that shut me out -
Heretic, rebel, a thing to flout.
But love and I had the wit to win -
We drew a circle that took them in.
The Episcopal Church in the United States stands proudly in the tradition of drawing the larger circle. Not long ago, the circle was expanded to include women clergy and Bishops. And the battle that currently rages in the Anglican Communion about gay priests and Bishops is about what we understand God's most basic message to be. I understand that message to be about love and understanding, which cannot exist in an environment where people are ostracized overtly or politely.
Finally, the tradition part of the tripod. I like the sacraments and the church year because they are, at the very least, mnemonic devices to keep me focused on a path that brings the divine into my consciousness on a regular basis. (And they are probably more than that, but I do not have much of a supernatural bent.) I also like hearing about great Christians from the past -- the Saints -- who exemplified the best things that our religion has done in the world, especially St. Francis and St. Benedict. Other "protestant" churches don't say anything about these people because for them there was a hiatus in "true" Christianity between 200 and 1600 AD.
I've probably said some igorant things here, not having any formal training in these matters. But I do have a great fondness for our Anglican and Episcopalian way. I'd like to hear what others have to say about it.
I can tell you why I am an Episcopalian. I like the whole theological style of this outfit. The Via Media. Balancing Scripture, reason and tradition. Maybe add to that common sense (though perhaps that falls under the "reason" category).
As to Scripture, it can be argued that we Episcopalians do not emphasize this sufficiently. We hear it read to us in the liturgy, which causes a somewhat choppy treatment of the text. And then the sermon explicates it to some limited extent. Frankly, that's enough for me. Weekly (and sometimes more often) bite-sized chunks. I grew up in a "fundie" church, where Bible texts are used to prove the most outlandish things without any tether to human reason. I don't want a church where I have to park my brain at the door and become a glazed-over yes man within. Don't beat me over the head with the Bible. I've had enough of that.
As for reason, I think any reasonable person can perceive that the path of the ethical and spiritual development of humankind is towards inclusiveness. Jesus constantly broke down the social codes of propriety and shame. He consorted with sinners and outcasts, and blew off the priestly caste. Jesus's approach foreshadowed the words Edwin Markham:
They drew a circle that shut me out -
Heretic, rebel, a thing to flout.
But love and I had the wit to win -
We drew a circle that took them in.
The Episcopal Church in the United States stands proudly in the tradition of drawing the larger circle. Not long ago, the circle was expanded to include women clergy and Bishops. And the battle that currently rages in the Anglican Communion about gay priests and Bishops is about what we understand God's most basic message to be. I understand that message to be about love and understanding, which cannot exist in an environment where people are ostracized overtly or politely.
Finally, the tradition part of the tripod. I like the sacraments and the church year because they are, at the very least, mnemonic devices to keep me focused on a path that brings the divine into my consciousness on a regular basis. (And they are probably more than that, but I do not have much of a supernatural bent.) I also like hearing about great Christians from the past -- the Saints -- who exemplified the best things that our religion has done in the world, especially St. Francis and St. Benedict. Other "protestant" churches don't say anything about these people because for them there was a hiatus in "true" Christianity between 200 and 1600 AD.
I've probably said some igorant things here, not having any formal training in these matters. But I do have a great fondness for our Anglican and Episcopalian way. I'd like to hear what others have to say about it.
posted by:
|
|
Unsubscribed |
-
Re: Why are you an Episcopalian?
Thu, August 18, 2005 - 9:32 AMI think you got it down solid. Congrats, you're a true Episcopalian. ;-)
Bob
-
Re: Why are you an Episcopalian?
Tue, August 23, 2005 - 9:39 AMI was raised a Lutheran in the Seattle area (where about a quarter of the population seems to be Scandinavian Lutherans). The Lutheran church in Seattle is quite liberal. For instance, I learned more about evolution in Sunday school than I did in public school.
When I left to go to college (first in LA and then in Cambridge, MA), I discovered that not all Lutherans are as open-minded and as filled with joy as the ones I grew up with. As a result, I never found a new church home and drifted away.
Then, in my mid-thirties, I decided I needed to "explore the spiritual." I attended a Universalist Unitarian church for a while, but "there wasn't any there there." Fortunately, I found the Episcopal Church. I joined St. George's Episcopal Church and became part of a warm, welcoming community where it's okay ask hard, even heretical questions. At St. George's, you don't have "leave your brain at the door" when you come to church on Sunday morning.
What really convinced me that the Episcopal Church was open-minded enough for me was Bishop John Spong and his books "Why Christianity Must Change or Die" and "Resurrection--Myth or Reality." These incredibly provocative books helped me focus in on what's at the core of my faith. -
-
Unsu...
Re: Why are you an Episcopalian?
Thu, August 25, 2005 - 2:48 PMI also appreciate Bishop Spong's books. I don't agree with everything he says, but he grapples with important issues that most other clerics tend to sweep under the carpet, such as the problem of theism in the scientific age.
I have drawn similar sustenance from Marcus Borg, "Meeting Jesus Again for the First Time" and "The Heart of Christianity"; J.M. Robinson, "Honest to God"; Paul Tillich, "The Shaking of the Foundations"; and Elaine Pagels, "The Gnostic Gospels" and "Beyond Belief: The Secret Gospel of Thomas".
As far as I'm concerned, no question should be off the table. It sounds like you have found an ideal parish.
-
-
Re: Why are you an Episcopalian?
Mon, September 19, 2005 - 4:41 PMI'm an Episcopalian because such people seem to have a more open mind and questioning attitude ...
I re-joined the local Episcopal Cathedral when all of the news hit the street regarding the election of Gene Robinson as a Bishop in New Hampshire .. I was really pleased at that particular event..
I'm Lez and my partner and I have been together for 19 years ... We even joke about how many hetro couples don't stay married for 19 years .. lol ..
I guess that the combination of ritual, scripture, common sense, and an ability to not simply follow the leader in terms of dogma makes us Episcopalians a more rational sort than many other denominations ...
-
Re: Why are you an Episcopalian?
Tue, November 15, 2005 - 10:10 AMI could say for tradition . . . because I was raised pretty much Episcopalean as was my mother. Her father's family adopted the Anglican tradition when my grandfather was a child and he didn't abandon The Communion although there were several churches they could not openly attend at the time. The family stayed Anglican dispite the fact that he had to baptize his daughters after the service was over and they had to enter through the back door of the church. He maintained his faith in the Communion even on those cold Sundays when he'd have to stoke up the stove in the workshop behind the church so that the few Black members of the congregation would be warm as he performed his duties as Lay reader, before they entered the sanctuary through the back door after service to recieve communion.
I am an Episcopalian because dispite it's shortcommings this Communion of Saints is always striving to build a stronger, inclusive fellowship within the Body of Christ. Like Jacob, we struggle with God. Working always to obey one of Jesus' last commandments, "Love thy neighbor, as thyself." We don't pretend to be perfect or, that our way is the only way to God.
There is beauty and tradition in our services. We don't wack people over the head with dogma or scripture. We don't have to jump, scream, holler, cry are even sing very well to minister to people's souls. We embrace, relate, and serve you coffee and fellowship after the service. And we halso have pancake dinners. -
-
Re: Why are you an Episcopalian?
Tue, November 15, 2005 - 7:53 PMBecause I don't have to check my brain at the door when I go to church. -
-
Re: Why are you an Episcopalian?
Wed, November 16, 2005 - 12:23 PMOh an we drink real wine with Communion -
-
Re: Why are you an Episcopalian?
Fri, November 25, 2005 - 1:26 PMYes...
I was raised as a roman catholic and always noticed that those receiving communion received the bread but never the wine ...
What's up with that ?? -
-
Unsu...
Re: Why are you an Episcopalian?
Tue, November 29, 2005 - 5:59 AM<< those receiving communion received the bread but never the wine>>
Paranoia about disease transmission, perhaps? -
-
Re: Why are you an Episcopalian?
Thu, December 22, 2005 - 9:42 AMBut wouldn't Communion Wine kill the grems, that stuff is all sorts of strong
-
-
Re: Why are you an Episcopalian?
Tue, November 29, 2005 - 6:08 AMIt was once reserved only for clergy.
-
-
-
-
-
Unsu...
Re: Why are you an Episcopalian?
Tue, November 29, 2005 - 6:43 AMI also like the fact that the Episcopal Church promotes peace and is speaking out against the Iraq madness. So is the Anglican Church generally.
The Episcopal Church stands for the things that Christ would have us stand for -- peace, love of even enemies, helping the poor and the sick, bringing hope to prisoners, and generally uplifting the marginalized. In short, everything that Bush is against, the Episcopal Church is for. This Church is a brave beacon of light during a dark time when the religious soul of this country has been perverted and manipulated by a hateful junta.
-
Re: Why are you an Episcopalian?
Wed, December 14, 2005 - 12:12 AMBenedict XVI!
